Insurance appraisal umpire · Anywhere in the lower 48

The neutral third on disputed property claims.

When the two appraisers can't agree, Eric Maslak reviews both positions, inspects the loss, and writes an award built to be signed — so the claim gets settled instead of stuck.

Request an umpire Download CV
200+
umpire files completed
2018
umpiring and appraising since
$1K–$1M+
claim sizes, residential & commercial
Lower 48
umpire files anywhere in the continental U.S.

How it works

From impasse to a signed award, in three steps.

01

Appointment

Both appraisers agree on Eric as umpire. Send the signed appointment papers and each side's estimate, and the file opens the same day.

02

Inspection

A solo inspection or a full panel walk-through — whichever the file needs. Every disputed line item is seen in person, not guessed from photos.

03

Award

Eric reviews both positions line by line and issues an award estimate with the award. Once two of the three panel members sign, it's binding and the file closes.

Why appraisers call Eric

He has built it, priced it, and argued both sides of it.

Fair awards come from knowing how a house actually goes together and how both sides read the policy. That is the whole job.

Built before he priced

Seven years in custom home construction, foundation to finish, with roofing systems from tear-off to install.

Both sides of the table

Has appraised for policyholders and for carriers, and holds public adjuster licenses in nine states.

Roofing depth

Slate, tile, wood shake, flat and laminate systems. Hail, ice, wind, tornado and hurricane losses, plus fire, water and collapse.

Clean, simple billing

One invoice to each appraiser for half the fee, a W-9 with every invoice, and the executed award in the file.

Request an umpire

Send the file. Eric confirms within one business day.

Include what you have — the rest can follow by email.

  • Insured, claim number and carrier
  • Loss address
  • Both appraisers' names and emails
  • Both estimates, if ready

Prefer email or a call?
eric@peakstoprairie.com
(307) 899-5495

Files anywhere in the lower 48. No account needed.

Curriculum vitae

Eric A. Maslak

Neutral umpire for disputed residential and commercial property claims, with a builder's eye and experience appraising for both policyholders and carriers.

Download CV (PDF) Request W-9

Experience

2018 – present
Owner & Umpire, Peaks To Prairie Claims Consulting

Umpire on appraisal panels for residential and commercial claims, solo and full-panel inspections, award estimates and awards. Party appraiser for insureds and insurers. Hail, ice, wind, tornado and hurricane; fire, water and collapse; slate, tile, wood shake, flat and laminate roofs.

2015 – 2018
Sr. Account Analyst, KeyBank N.A.

Risk review and analysis for structured finance and middle-market lending.

2011 – 2015
Field operations, Oil & Gas

Team leadership and heavy equipment operation under extensive OSHA safety training.

2003 – 2010
Residential builder, Maslak Construction

Custom homes from foundation to completion; roofing systems from demolition to install. Cody, Wyoming.

Certifications & education

  • Public Adjuster — CO, WY, MT, ND, NE, KS, MO, OK, ID
  • Property, Casualty, Life & Health — CO, 2015 – 2018
  • OSHA 10, lifetime
  • B.A., Politics & Liberal Arts — Ave Maria University
QR code: save Eric's contact card
Save Eric's contact

Scan with your phone's camera to add his number and email.